Resin vs tarmac - Advice if cost wasn't an issue

Setts and cobbles, tarmac, asphalt, resin systems, concrete whether it's plain, patterned or stencilled, gravels, etc.
Post Reply
HitchCheshire
Posts: 2
Joined: Fri Sep 15, 2017 1:08 pm
Location: Cheshire

Post: # 114620Post HitchCheshire

Hi Everyone, This has probably been asked a ton of times so apologies in advance. I have been tasked by my family to sort a driveway and dropped kerb for the house. With the quotes I have had both tarmac and resin are just about within budget (albeit with the tarmac considerably cheaper than resin!) so cost isn't necessarily a factor.
The resin contractor has done work locally and has had repeat business (one chap brought them back 4 years later for a different project)
The tarmac contractor has also done work locally including some fairly large commercial projects.
Neither sub contract work - so are trusted as much as they can be.

I am just trying to work out whether the resin is worth the extra cost. As both contractors while trying to stay neutral are offering up a little bit of scaremongering about the others products!

Theoretically it will be a drive on/drive off(providing we don't get people blocking us in by parking on the dropped kerb!)

Is resin considered to be more durable in the long-term?
Has the lifespan of tarmac dropped now refinery process have become more advanced as some websites talk about?

I have spent the last 2 weeks trying to narrow the choice down but don't seem to be getting anywhere. Appreciate any comments or suggestions from anyone!
Nick

Pablo
Posts: 1990
Joined: Sun Mar 25, 2007 10:49 pm
Location: N/Ireland

Post: # 114622Post Pablo

Hi Nick,
Can you clarify what kind of Tarmac ? (Bitmac, SMA, Asphalt etc)
And what kind of Resin? (Bound or bonded) also what it's being laid onto?
Cheers
Can't see it from my house

HitchCheshire
Posts: 2
Joined: Fri Sep 15, 2017 1:08 pm
Location: Cheshire

Post: # 114623Post HitchCheshire

Hi Pablo, just checked the quote for the preferred tarmac option and they haven't stated the type of tarmac being used, I had assumed asphalt.
For the resin option it's resin bound - we wanted the porous option.

Cheers
Nick

Post Reply